The Best Beers to Pair with 5 Girl Scout Cookies

Beer? Yes. Girl Scout Cookies? Absolutely. Together?

We all know the time of year. Maybe your New Year’s Resolution diet is still holding up, maybe it’s long forgotten. Regardless, we all fold in the presence of Girl Scout Cookies, which wreak havoc on waistlines across America between January and April. Whatever your taste, there’s one for you. And surprisingly, they can get even better.

Each year around this time, Fullsteam Brewery of Durham, North Carolina, holds weekly events featuring Girl Scout Cookie flights — five of their locally sourced beers uniquely paired with five of the signature cookies you know so well.

Not convinced? Give one (or, ahem, all five) of the combinations below a go. If nothing else, you’re still drinking beer and eating cookies.

Cookie: Lemonades

Beer Style: Pale Ale

These two are a year-round Southern combination that never goes out of style. Humidity is a modern pale ale that’s hazy and slightly sticky — a perfect complement to the tangy shortbread cookie.

Best Widely Available Options:

• Sierra Nevada, Pale Ale
• Oskar Blues, Dale’s Pale Ale
• Half Acre Beer Co, Daisy Cutter Pale Ale
• Founders Brewing, Mosaic Promise
• Deschutes Brewery, Mirror Pond Pale Ale

 

Cookie: Shortbread

Beer Style: Kentucky Common

The tart apple notes of the Kentucky Common are perfectly tempered by the sweet, buttery crisps of the shortbread cookie. The tart and smooth sour mash dark ale is 95% locally sourced and aged briefly in oak. You’ll get every bit of that when you try one after the other.

Best Widely Available Options:

• Anchor Brewing, Anchor Steam Beer (for another worker’s common)
• New Belgium, La Folie (for another sour, wood aged ale)

 

Cookie: Caramel Delights

Beer Style: Winter Warmer

The caramel adds a rich extra flavor to this malty winter ale. The heavy use of sweet and savory persimmons (translation: “fruit of the gods”) in the First Frost plays well with the sweet coconut of the cookie.

Best Widely Available Options:

• Great Lakes Brewing, Great Lakes Christmas Ale
• Deschutes Brewery, Jubelale
• Anderson Valley Brewing, Winter Solstice Seasonal Ale
• Anchor Brewing, Christmas Ale
• Thirsty Dog Brewing, 12 Dogs Of Christmas Ale

 

Cookie: Thin Mints

Beer Style: Witbier

Perhaps the most surprising combo of them all. Brewed with North Carolina honey, oats, and Tellicherry black pepper, Beasley’s Honey has bright fresh cracked pepper that bridges the cookie’s intense mint. Seriously, it’s not nearly as strange as it sounds.

The Best Widely Available Option:

• Allagash Brewing, Allagash White

 

Cookie: Peanut Butter Patties

Beer Style: Porter

The classic coffee and cookies combo remixed with a modern twist. Coffee is for Closers is made with coffee beans, chocolate, and malt. The dark style of the beer pairs nicely with intense, nutty flavor of the cookie.

Best Widely Available Options:

• Deschutes Brewery, Black Butte Porter
• Anchor Brewing, Porter
• Founders Brewing Co, Porter
• Great Lakes Brewing Co, Edmund Fitzgerald
• Maine Beer Co, King Titus